|
Property Auctions - Do you really need a valuer? - Howard Gooddie
Did you absorb that article in Developers' Notebook on tax saving ideas?
It really gave me reminders of quite a few legitimate tax items that
are worth considering. I gave it a second read the other day and felt
the time was still well spent. It reminded me, too, that I have just
received the news that we have secured a speaker from the accountants
WJB Chiltern for our next Conference on May 25th. If you don't note
it elsewhere in this edition of PAN, we shall all be at the University
of Westminster at 309 Regent Street (easily accessible in the West End)
from 8.30am to 11pm - if you stay for the networking supper at the end.
As I have been saying to all the enquirers, "I look forward to seeing
you there". I am sure Peter will be warning you as the Order Forms go
out shortly we have already received nearly as many expressions of interest
as there are places, so make sure you book early.
Thinking about other professionals has encouraged me to consider again
the facet of my own work which I enjoy a close second to standing on
the rostrum - building surveying and valuation. Strangely enough, I
am going to encourage you to think very hard about how often you will
need an expensive and thorough valuation and survey before you go out
to buy at an auction. Later on in this article I am going to plagiarise
part of my own book and for this I apologise to all of our readers who
already own the printed word or the CD ROM.
If you are buying for restoration and resale, unless you
are very confident of your own abilities and judgment you may well feel
you need guidance from a builder on costs and from a selling agent on
your eventual realisation figure. I would hope that you already have
both in tow on the basis that they have an opportunity to profit from
your endeavours as well as you. You might already have decided to cut
your builder in for part of the profit, although this should not stop
you from ensuring that he is fully aware of how his costs are quantified
and how the profit, or dare I say, any loss, is to be split. With a
common sense approach you should be able to get a pretty good idea yourself
of what needs doing to a property or, alternatively, be capable enough
to decide whether you need the advice of a building surveyor or structural
engineer. Let me run through many of the items to look for that a surveyor
ran through at our last Conference.
The first look. Always start by a slow, and I mean slow, general look
round inside and out to get your bearings and familiarise yourself with
the property. If you can, choose a time when it's raining (and if it
isn't the first time, go back when it is). There's nothing like a cold
wet shower down your collar to draw attention to faulty rainwater goods!
Now start to use your common sense and start looking about you more
carefully.
1. Structural failures. No one needs to be a surveyor to judge a wall
is out of true or a window frame is crooked. Who straightens all the
pictures in you house after the dusting? Look for noticeable cracks
at the corners of door and window frames, the line of mortar in brickwork
being crooked or bent and for settlement over window and door arches.
Look for ceiling cornices that have cracked and crooked door lintels
inside. If you must be like an old-fashioned surveyor, carry a marble
in you pocket to check how sloping is the floor that your sensitive
feet have already detected - or if you must, take a spirit level, just
in case! Be particularly suspicious of cracks in walls that run beneath
the damp proof course level. For good measure it is worthwhile giving
a cursory look at other houses nearby to see whether they are suffering
settlement. If they do, go back and check for incipient cracks in the
same places in the structure of the one for which you are thinking of
bidding. Only now is the time, if you are suspicious, to start talking
to a surveyor or engineer.
2. Damp. Damp should be obvious. Smell it or feel the humidity; look
for old and new damp stains; run your hands over the lower half of the
ground floor walls or indulge yourself in a damp meter, if you are feeling
adventurous. Then trace back the reasons for any damp you find. Leaking
roof or gutters? Faulty downspouts or overflows? An old and faulty damp
proof course? Faulty plumbing? They are all curable, at a cost. Then
go out and find out that cost.
3. Wood. Faults. Look carefully for the flight holes and you will
know you have found woodworm. Make sure you lift the carpets and the
linoleum and that you look in dark small corners, under stairs and in
roof spaces. If there is fresh dust and clean holes then specialist
treatment is necessary. Once you find it somewhere, suspect it elsewhere.
Any self-respecting woodworm turns into a little fly in it's third year
and goes prospecting! That's when it has bored its way out through the
clean hole you have found. Woodworm is treatable. Wet rot is mere deterioration
in timber which has been subjected to damp and is treatable - just look
for the crinkled rotted looking timbers and replace them after you have
cured the cause of the damp which caused it in the first place. Dry
rot is vicious. Smell, if you are lucky, as you walk into the property
- like a cross between wet seaweed and a clutch of vile fungus up close.
And that's what it is. A fungus that can grow large coloured fungous
mushroom-like growths. It starts with an airborne seed that fruitfully
falls on damp wood in stagnant surroundings. It then grows long thin
white tendril roots that go seeking dry fresh timber for further sustenance.
I have seen the roots grow through an 18in thick brick wall and fill
a dry cellar beyond with a thick cotton wool type mesh in 6 months.
The roots will spread everywhere. You will really need a good and thorough
specialist to poison and eradicate this menace and cure the conditions
that fostered it's growth in the first place. Make sure you get a contractor
who gives you a guarantee that is worth much more that the paper it's
written on! Dry rot is not for treatment by amateurs and your future
buyer or mortgagee will certainly need to have the guarantee. Furthermore,
that guarantee is very likely only to cover the new timber that has
been installed! It will not cover you or your buyer or the mortgagor
against future attack of the timbers that have not been replaced.
4. The Cosmetics. This perhaps is not an item which can be covered
too lightly, but it should be immediately obvious to you if the bathroom
and kitchen fittings need replacing. How are the plumbing and electric
installations? How's the decorating, inside and out? Don't skimp on
any of these and don't use paint and wallpaper just to cover up any
faults.
5. The Exterior. Too often I feel people don't think about gardens,
paths and boundaries. What was that about first impressions? In housing
they always count. Think of your first thoughts as you began the first
inspection.
So now I've frightened the life out of you! If I have, maybe you should
think about getting a surveyor in anyway! There are really three approaches:
1. You can call in a builder you feel you can trust. This has the
advantage that you have the practical approach and a chance of a realistically
quick approximate costing. On the other hand you probably have lost
any chance of pecuniary recourse if he misadvised you.
2. You can get a full building survey. If you do this you should ask
the surveyor to give you a full and detailed structural survey. He or
she will then carry out a detailed inspection of the building and will
give you a relatively comprehensive report on the nature of, and defects
in the structure. He should be able to give you approximate costs for
bringing the property up to scratch and to advise you on appropriate
specialist firms, if you require any. The professional surveyor may
well be able to advise you on market values as well. This approach is
relatively expensive and you may decide that your own initial survey
will be sufficient for you to decide whether you need to spend on the
cost of such a report before you go to the auction. 3. You can obtain
a House Buyer's report of the kind promoted by the Royal Institution
of Chartered Surveyors. This report will certainly cost less than the
full building survey but is in my opinion of only limited value. You
get what you pay for and this report will only give you sketchy comments
on likely problems in you building.
And how, you may ask, is a property valued? Avid readers of my past
columns, or my book or my CD ROM (see later), I'm afraid may already
be too well aware of my answer to that question, so maybe I should avoid
answering it this time. I will instead treat you to a copy of my Valuers'
Checklist so that you can do it for yourself.
-
Obtain as much preliminary information about the property as possible,
in particular:
(a) Tenure of site.
(b) Any tenancies.
(c) Size and extent of accommodation
and site.
(d) Any peculiarities of the district,
situation and site.
(e) Recent sales, purchases or lettings
of the building or ones close by.
-
Thoroughly inspect the property inside and out.
-
Ascertain any outstanding defects and deficiencies that need remedying
to bring the property up to good standard.
-
Make a provisional estimate of the costs of curing those defects
or deficiencies using specialists where appropriate.
-
Judge the effect of those costs on the mind of a hypothetical buyer.
-
Obtain details of recent transactions of comparable properties.
-
Adjust those transactions for any rise or fall in the market over
the period in which they have taken place.
-
Compare and adjust the information from those comparables so that
it relates as closely as possible to the subject property.
-
For vacant properties use as far as possible values from other
vacant comparables.
-
For investment properties consider rental levels as well as yields
of comparables.
-
Allow for differing states of repair.
-
Come to a conclusion in the light of your analysis which you would
hope will equal that of a would-be-buyer.
And, finally, let me give you the wisdom of the very first valuation
lecture I ever attended at Cambridge by a curly red-headed Chartered
Surveyor, C.W.N. Miles, who was so good that he subsequently became
a Professor and the Principal of the Department of Land Economy at Reading
University.
"If" he said "you are going out to value a property in a district
with which you are not familiar, talk about it over lunch at the local
pub, ask where it is in the local Post Office and make sure that you
need to ask the way at least three times before you get there. By then
you should not even need to go to see it, having been told all about
it before you arrived!"
Unfortunately, with the local pub and post office now gone, you may
have to rely on the local estate agent, the postman, your wits and my
advice, but I'm sure you will come to the same conclusions! Good luck
in your research.
|